Roof claim underpaid in Florida?
A small check for a damaged roof is one of the most common problems we see. Here is why roof claims come in low and how to push back.
Common reasons roof claims are underpaid
- Repair instead of replacement. The insurer pays to patch a few shingles or tiles when the damage is wider, or when the patch will not match the rest of the roof.
- Wear and tear. Storm damage is called age or deterioration.
- Missing items. Underlayment, drip edge, flashing, permits, code upgrades and removal of the old roof are left out of the estimate.
- Depreciation. The first payment is reduced for the roof’s age. Some policies pay older roofs on a schedule based on age, so the declarations page matters.
- Interior damage left out. Leaks into ceilings, insulation and walls are not included.
Florida rules that affect roof claims
Florida law requires repairs to reasonably match in quality, color and size when a matching repair is not possible. If the repaired area will not reasonably match, the claim can include more of the roof.
Florida’s building code also matters. Since a 2022 change, a roof built under the 2007 code or later can generally be repaired rather than replaced even when more than 25% of it is damaged. Older roofs may still qualify for full replacement. These rules decide whether the claim is a repair or a replacement.
How to challenge a low roof estimate
- Ask for the insurer’s full itemized estimate and photos.
- Get your own inspection with close-up photos of the damage pattern: creases, lifted tabs, cracked tiles, missing granules from hail.
- Compare line by line: underlayment, flashing, drip edge, permits, code items, removal.
- Submit the evidence and request a reinspection, or use the dispute options in your policy.
- Watch the deadlines: a supplemental claim must be filed within 18 months of the date of loss.
Common questions
Should I let my contractor talk to the insurer?
Your contractor can help document damage, but only a licensed public adjuster or attorney can negotiate the claim for you. Many contractors refer homeowners to us for that reason.
The insurer already paid. Can I still get more?
Yes. If the damage is worth more than you were paid, a supplemental claim can be filed within 18 months of the date of loss.
What does a public adjuster cost?
Florida law caps public adjuster fees at 20% of claim payments. For a claim tied to a declared state of emergency, the cap is 10% for the first year after the declaration. We put our fee in writing before you sign anything, and it is a percentage of your claim payments.
Talk to a licensed public adjuster
Tell us what happened. We’ll review your policy and your claim, explain your options and tell you honestly whether we can help.
